中华皮肤科杂志 ›› 1996, Vol. 29 ›› Issue (4): 223-225.

• 论著 •    下一篇

随机双盲安慰剂对照评价米诺地尔治疗女性雄激素性秃发

李茂超, 苏伟, 王慧英, 王侠生   

  1. 上海华山医院皮肤科 200040
  • 收稿日期:1995-08-28 修回日期:1995-12-07 发布日期:1996-08-15

Randomized Double-blind Placebo-Controled Evaluation of Topical Minoxidil in the Treatment of Fe-male Androgonetic Alopecia

Li Maochao, Su Wei, Wang Huiying   

  1. Department of Der-matology, Nanjing General Hospital of PLA, Nanjing 210002
  • Received:1995-08-28 Revised:1995-12-07 Published:1996-08-15

摘要: 用米诺地尔治疗男性雄激素性秃发已取得了较好的疗效,为进一步研究米诺地尔治疗秃发的疗效,进行了外用3%米诺地尔治疗女性雄激素性秃发的研究.方法:采用随机双盲安慰剂对照前瞻性研究.以医师与患者共同观察,毛发计数和拍照作为疗效判断方法.3%米诺地尔生发水或安慰剂2ml外用,日2次.治疗4个月后,安慰剂组改用米诺地尔.病例:选择年龄<60岁、病程<20年的女性雄激素性秃发患者.治疗组24例,对照组21例.结果:观察治疗4个月,治疗组、对照组有效率分别为58.3%(14/24)和14.2%(3/21),P=0.0023;治疗12个月两组有效率分别为72.2%(13/18)和73.3%(11/15).毛发计数,治疗组治疗4个月非毳毛计数60%病例超过治疗前水平,治疗12个月65%病例超过治疗前水平,32%病例超过治疗4个月水平.治疗1~2个月毳毛均数上升,治疗3~4个月毳毛向非毳毛转变,毳毛数减少;治疗2个月非毳毛均数开始上升,并连续上升8个月后平缓不再上升;治疗4个月时治疗组与对照组非毳毛计数分别为20.7±67.0和10.6±64.8根(P=0.030).部分病例治疗前后拍照也显示较为理想.虽然少数病例被判定为治疗无效,但患者认为用药可以控制秃发发展,故愿意长期使用.

关键词: 米诺地尔, 脱发

Abstract: We have obtained satisfactory result in the treatment of male patern baldness with topical minoxidil preparation. For further studying we performed the study of female androgenetic alopecia treated topicaly with 3% minoxidil.Methods: Randomized double-blind placebo controled prospective study was used.Eficacy was determined by doctor's and patients' observation,hair count and taking picture.Either 2ml of 3% minoxidil solution or placebo was used twice daily.Subjects who began with placebo were crosedover to 3% minoxidil after the first four months,and both groups continued to use minoxidil for an additional 8 months in open trial.Patients:Patients with female androgenetic alopecia age <60 years old,duration of disease <20 years,and local residents entered into the study.There were 24 cases in the treatment group and 21 in the control group.Results: Doctor's and patients' observation showed that the rates of efectiveness of both minoxidil and control groups were 58.3% (14/24) and 14.2% (3/21) respectively (P=0.0023),after four month treatment;72.2% (13/18) and 73.3% (11/15) after twelve months. 60% casesin the treatment group the nonvelus hairs at four months outnumbered those at baseline,65% cases at twelve months,and the hair count in 32% casesat twelve months was greater than that at four months.The mean velus hair count of minoxidil group increased after 1~2 montht reatment,velus hairs appeared to change into nonvelus hairs after 3~4 months and velus hairs began to decrease.Nonvelus hairs began to increase after two months and continued to increase for eight months.Mean nonvelus hairs at the end of four months were 20.7±67.0 in minoxidil group and 10.6±64.8 incontrol group,the diference is significant (P=0.03).The photographs of some patients taken before and after treatment also showed satistactory result.Although some of the patients are of no efect,they are wiling to use the drug for a long period for the control of the development of alopecia.

Key words: Minoxidil, Alopecia